The Seller Disclosure Nightmare: Evan and Claire’s Story

The Dream Home Turned Haunted

After months of searching, a Minnesota couple—Evan and Claire—finally found their dream home. It was everything they wanted: charming, affordable, and move-in ready.

The sellers – Mark and Diane seemed honest and kind. The Seller’s Disclosure Statement looked clean.

Evan and Claire signed, moved in, and imagined years of happy memories ahead.

But within weeks, the dream home revealed its darker side.


The Hidden Horror Beneath the Surface

There were skeletons in the closet. (Ok, not literally).

It began with a faint musty smell in the basement. Minnesota homes can get damp, right?

Then came a storm. Water seeped through cracks, carpet bubbled, and paint peeled to reveal black mold growing underneath.

When they called a contractor, the verdict was chilling:

“This didn’t happen overnight. These problems have been here for years.”

Evan and Claire dug deeper—and discovered the previous owners had patched over water damage, replaced drywall, and conveniently “forgotten” to mention it.


When Sellers Stay Silent

Under Minnesota Seller Disclosure Laws (Minn. Stat. §§ 513.52–513.60), home sellers are legally required to disclose any known material facts that could affect the property’s value or safety. That includes water intrusion, foundation issues, mold, or structural defects.

The sellers’ statement had said:

“No known water intrusion.”
“No foundation issues.”
“No mold or moisture problems.”

But neighbors told a different story—about past flooding, failed sump pumps, and contractors called out for “repairs”.

What the sellers had done wasn’t just careless—it was a violation of Minnesota disclosure law.


The Legal Fallout

Evan and Claire had no choice but to move out and pay for extensive mold remediation and foundation repairs.

With their attorney’s help, they uncovered emails, contractor invoices, and insurance claims showing the sellers knew about the problems long before the sale.

The result? A seller nondisclosure claim that led to costly damages and attorney’s fees for the sellers – and a headache for the buyers.

Their once-perfect home became the setting of a real estate horror story—one that could have been avoided with honest disclosure.


How to Avoid a Seller Disclosure Nightmare

If you’re buying a home in Minnesota, here’s how to stay protected under Minnesota real estate disclosure requirements:

  • Read the Seller’s Disclosure carefully. Don’t ignore vague or incomplete answers.

  • Hire an independent, qualified home inspector. Even new-looking homes can hide expensive issues.

  • Document everything. Save inspection reports, emails, and texts—especially if something seems “off.”

  • Consult a Minnesota real estate attorney before closing if you suspect a seller is withholding information.

The scariest part of this story isn’t the mold—it’s the silence. The sellers’ decision not to disclose what they knew cost everyone time, money, and peace of mind.


Don’t Let Your Minnesota Home Purchase Turn Into a Horror Story


Whether you’re buying or selling, our experienced Minnesota real estate attorneys can help you understand your rights under Minnesota Seller Disclosure Laws and protect your investment from costly surprises.

Contact Markve & Zweifel today to schedule a consultation.